Giraffe
Catalog #082 tbd
-
A large carved wood carousel giraffe in the "leaf-eater" pose — neck stretched fully upward with the head turned back and slightly skyward, mouth open as if reaching to feed from a high branch — attributed to Charles I.D. Looff (reported). The body is finished in warm tawny-cream tones with darker russet and ochre patches rendered through soft paint shading to suggest the natural mottled coat of a giraffe rather than literal carved markings. The figure stands on all four slender, naturalistically proportioned legs in an alert standing pose, with a long tail descending and curling toward the rear leg, terminating in a carved tuft. The head is carved with characterful detail: open mouth showing teeth, glass eye, alert ears with carved internal structure, and the characteristic ossicones suggested through carved bone-stub form. Trappings are restrained but well-defined: a saddle blanket in deep russet-red with green saddle plate and dark border trim outlined in fine yellow piping; a wider belly band continuing the red-with-yellow-pipe scheme; and a finely scrolled green cantle terminating in a carved spiral at the rear of the saddle. The overall palette is grounded in earth tones — ochres, sienna reds, dark greens — without the elaborate jeweling associated with later Coney Island work.
-
Acquired at a Butterfield auction in San Francisco (reported). The owner recounts the transport home as part of the acquisition story: with the seats folded down in their cruiser, the giraffe was driven home with its head extending between the front seats (reported). A stop in Reno is referenced in the trip back, though the owner is uncertain of the exact sequence. No specific acquisition date or hammer price was recalled in the interview: "I don't remember what we paid for it" (reported).
The Butterfield name in San Francisco operated under that designation through 2002, when the firm was acquired by Bonhams; it then operated as Bonhams & Butterfields and is now Bonhams San Francisco (sourced — Bonhams company history). The owner's reference to "Butterfield" suggests an acquisition before or during the early years of that transition, but the specific sale and date have not yet been retrieved.
The owner's interview includes a passing reference to "Torino in between this" (reported, phonetic — unresolved). The most plausible interpretation is "Tobin in between this," referring to a possible examination or intermediate involvement by Tobin Fraley, the carousel historian known to have examined other pieces in the collection. This is flagged for clarification.
-
Acquired at Butterfields, San Francisco; pre-Butterfields ownership and original carousel of operation are not documented in the current submission. Recovery of the specific sale catalog — feasible given that Bonhams maintains a continuous archive of Butterfields sales since 2002, and other public catalog repositories preserve earlier Butterfields catalogs — is the highest-value research action for this entry, and would likely carry whatever pre-consignment provenance language was assigned.
-
Charles I.D. Looff (1852–1918) is best known for the Coney Island carousel tradition he founded with the first carousel installed at Coney Island in 1876, going on to produce more than fifty carousels across Brooklyn, Rhode Island, and California. While the bulk of Looff's documented output is horses, the originating workshop did carve a small range of menagerie figures for variety — most consistently camels, giraffes, and goats — for inclusion on larger machines (sourced — Traeger Travel documentation of the 1906 San Francisco Looff carousel; Heritage Museums & Gardens; Slater Park; Spokane Riverfront Park). The 1906 San Francisco Looff carousel (Yerba Buena Gardens / Playland at the Beach lineage) is documented as having included a giraffe among its menagerie animals. The Slater Park Looff carousel in Pawtucket, Rhode Island, retains one operating giraffe among its 44 horses and six menagerie figures. The Spokane Riverfront Park Looff carousel (1909) likewise carries a giraffe among its surviving menagerie (all sourced). The 1908 Heritage Museums & Gardens Looff carousel includes a giraffe among the menagerie figures attributed to other hands working alongside the Looff workshop (sourced).
Looff giraffes are infrequently encountered on the private market — substantially less often than the originating workshop's horses, and somewhat less often than its camels. AntiqueCarousels.com has listed a c. 1885 Looff giraffe — described as a very early example from the original Brooklyn factory with "simple trappings on the large, realistically carved-to-scale figure" and an older restoration — at $12,000 (sourced). A Charles Looff carousel giraffe has appeared in the LiveAuctioneers price-result archive with no current hammer figure retrieved (sourced). A Looff carousel camel — the most directly comparable menagerie form from the same workshop — appears in the secondary market as "attributed to Charles Looff Carved and Painted Carousel Camel Figure, Restored" (sourced — LiveAuctioneers).
The "leaf-eater" pose — neck stretched upward with the head turned back to feed — is a recognized carousel-giraffe form documented across Philadelphia-school and Coney Island workshops; AntiqueCarousels.com has listed a c. 1905 Dentzel "Leaf-Eater" giraffe, confirming the terminology and the pose as an established type (sourced). The pose is the more dynamic of the two principal giraffe forms in American Golden Age work, the alternative being a straight-necked stander; both forms occur across multiple makers.
Surviving giraffes from the originating workshop are concentrated on the small number of operating Looff carousels still in service; private-market examples are rare occurrences rather than regular sale lots.
-
The photograph shows a beautifully restored figure. Paint is intact and lustrous across the body; the russet-red trappings paint is crisp with clean yellow piping; the green cantle scrollwork is well-defined. The painted giraffe-coat shading is naturalistic and integrated without the harsh outline often seen in lesser restoration work. Glass eye in place. Mouth carving, teeth, and tongue are clean. The slender legs show no visible damage and the tail is intact with its tuft. No active losses, splits, or repaint stress visible in the available image. Surface finish is smooth and even.
Restorer not identified in the current submission. The quality of the work is consistent with the named studios documented across this collection (Pam Hessey / Hawk's Eye Studio; Rich DeCuir; Lise Liepman), but direct attribution is pending owner clarification.
-
Medium — Looff attribution is owner-reported and consistent with the workshop's documented menagerie production, but the visual evidence alone could support either a Looff or a Philadelphia-school attribution; without the Butterfields catalog entry or other documentation, the specific attribution is not independently confirmed. The "leaf-eater" form is well-documented. The acquisition venue is reported and venue-consistent with the timing implied.
-
Owner interview (voice transcript) — primary source for maker attribution, acquisition venue, transport story, and the unresolved "Torino" reference
Owner-supplied photograph (single image, romance side, full figure)
Bonhams (bonhams.com) — corporate history confirming the Butterfields acquisition in 2002 and the continuous San Francisco operation
AntiqueCarousels.com — c. 1885 Looff giraffe listing (Brooklyn factory) and c. 1905 Dentzel "Leaf-Eater" giraffe listing confirming the pose terminology
Heritage Museums & Gardens — Looff carousel facts page documenting the originating workshop's menagerie animal range
Slater Park Looff Carousel (Pawtucket, RI) — operating Looff carousel with giraffe documentation
Spokane Riverfront Park Looff Carrousel — operating Looff carousel with giraffe documentation, installed 1909
Traeger Travel — documentation of the 1906 San Francisco Looff carousel menagerie program including a giraffe
LiveAuctioneers / Charlton Hall Auctions — comparable carousel giraffe records